Slow Buffalo LinkStation
I bought a Buffalo LinkStation 250Mb last week to ease the pressure on my laptop of my rapidly diminishing hard disk space. Plugging it in to my network via my hub presented no initial problems and the disk showed up on my Mac and I was able to mount it as a remote drive. Unfortunately when I attempted to copy a file across to it it sat there for ages. It appeared to be copying but at an excrutiatingly slow speed. After 10 minutes I gave up and cancelled the copy. It had only managed to copy around 700k of the file in 10 minutes! Not good.
I proceeded to spend a good hour or so trying to diagnose why it was so slow before I gave up. Searching the net reveals several other people with the same problem but no solution; some others have even sent the LinkStation back to Buffalo and I was beginning to think this was going to be the only option.
Throwing good money after bad I decided to upgrade my 10Base-T hub. I needed an extra port anyway so I bought a 100Base-T hub with more ports and plugged the LinkStation into that. They're dirt cheap these days anyway. For some unknown reason this seems to have cured the LinkStation. Now it's not as quick as a disk plugged directly into the laptop but I never expected that. It appears that the LinkStation does not work with a 10Base-T hub even though it's meant to support it. I can't see how the ten-fold increase in transmission speed accounts for the dramatic performance increase so it looks like something more fundamental is wrong.
If anyone ends up at this page looking for the solution to a slow LinkStation I recommend checking that your hub is quick enough to support it.
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
Another one
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
Re: Netgear Gigabit and Linkstation Pro
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
5 Mbyte/s is the speed for drag and drop copying.
With FTP that speed increases to 8 Mbyte/s for a single large file, the average is less for many smaller files.
With gigabit Networking I got 12 Myte/sec (drag and drop) and 15 Mbyte/s with FTP.
For us Linux guys, it is even slower if you copy the data accross an SMB mount (ie. access the samba share through a mount point. I did this so I could script the backups). Forget NFS. It's not supported.
This device is a huge disappointment. It's just too slow for backups. The box says ("as fast as USB 2.0 !"). My external 80 Gb disk, actually an Archos AV380 media player (an excellent item) achieves 20 Mbyte/s drag and drop, and that's a 2.5" disk several years old. A modern 3.5" disk would be even faster I am sure.
Other gripes: the web interface is slow and of disappointing quality. The page loading time is 5 or 10 seconds, and over 30 seconds if you change a setting. Sometimes the Linkstation is visible on my network, sometimes it is not (not necessarily the Linkstation's fault). There can be permissions issues (at the moment, I can't rename a file on the Linkstation).
On balance, I don't know why anybody in their right mind would buy a NAS. Buy an external USB disk and carry it from PC to PC if necessary. Fast, no issues with networking or permissions and no flaky web interface to absorb hours of your time
.
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation [TEST]
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation [TEST]
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation [TEST]
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
Re: Slow Buffalo LinkStation
- Upgrade the firmware to the latest version.
- Set a Static IP address - do not use DHCP
- Connect it to a Switch and NOT A HUB. (Hubs send all traffic to all ports, where a switch will direct it only to the required port, meaning a 100M switch has an effective throughput MANY times greater than a 100M Hub) - if your PC has gigabit, then use a gigabit (1000M) switch
- Use a good quality Cat5e patch cable. (I use Blackbox cables)
- Do NOT use the BUffalo software. It is unnecessary. Just either map a drive or use a UNC path.
Finally remember that the transfer speed is limited by several factors:
- The slowest part of the network - If you are using a wireless connection this will be the limiting factor, and it is highly unlikely you will get anywhere near rated wireless speed.
- The speed at which data can be read from the source drive (PC or linkstation)
- The speed at which data can be written to the destination drive (PC or Linkstation) which will always be slower than read speed.
Hope this helps.